School trustees OK sale of South Mission property
by Patricia Walsh
Published - 07/03/12 - 04:12 PM | 4214 views | 2 2 comments | 6 6 recommendations | email to a friend | print
San Diego Unified School District (SDUSD) trustees voted to sell this district property at 825 Santa Barbara Place as part of a move to liquidate an estimated $26 million in real estate assets to offset the district’s projected $120 million deficit. Photo by Don Balch I Beach & Bay Press
view slideshow (3 images)
Point Loma Mandarin Chinese program moves to Mission Bay Cluster

To raise money to offset a projected $120 million budget deficit, the San Diego Unified School District continued its path to sell Barnard Elementary School in Point Loma and separately agreed to move that campus’ Mandarin Chinese language program into the Mission Bay cluster of schools.

School board members also approved the “intent to sell” 2.23 acres of oceanfront property in South Mission Beach, as well as five other district-owned properties. The move to sell the assets, valued at more than

$26 million, received the supermajority 4-1 vote it needed to pass.

Trustee Scott Barnett, whose District C is home to the largest and most valuable real estate elements on the table — the 9.37-acre Barnard site and the South Mission Beach property — opposed the sale as he has since the board began voting on the issue in November.

In a separate vote, trustees unanimously approved moving the Mandarin-language program out of Barnard and the Point Loma Cluster to Bayview Terrace Elementary School in the Mission Bay Cluster. To accommodate the move, Bayview Terrace Elementary School will be closed and those students will be absorbed into other elementary schools in Mission Bay. The change will take effect beginning in the 2013-14 school year.

During a rare Friday night school board meeting held June 22, Barnett decried the decision by colleagues as short-sighted.

The Mission Beach Center is located in South Mission Beach at 818 and 825 Santa Barbara Place between the bay and ocean. The district is projecting a minimum bid of $11 million for the land. The Barnard site is expected to raise a minimum of $9 million.

“We’re about to sell one of the best pieces of real estate this district has and it’s like selling your grandma’s jewelry to pay the rent,” Barnett said.

Pointing to a map of the land in Mission Beach, Barnett said, “This piece of real estate — that’s the Pacific Ocean, that’s the bay. It’s one the best pieces of real estate in the world and we are going to sell it in the worst real estate market since the Great Depression for one-time revenues. Once we sell it, it’s gone.

“It’s absolutely absurd and probably this will go down as one of the most boneheaded things this school board has ever done.”

Other district real estate to be sold are Camp Elliot in Tierrasanta for $2.7 million; Bay Terrace 11, a parcel of land in south San Diego worth $3 million; and three residential lots in Linda Vista with a total price tag of $900,000. The total net sale price of all properties represents about 18 percent of the district’s projected $120 million deficit.

A line of questioning from Trustee Kevin Beiser revealed uncertainty among San Diego Unified staff about a district subcommittee’s report that did not advocate sales of all properties.

Staff also said they did not engage communities in discussion about the sales at the cluster level or with local planning groups. Phil Stover, deputy director of business development, said it was up to neighborhood planning groups to work with buyers once sales were finalized. Beiser suggested leasing properties to generate long-term revenue before anything is sold. Each property sale/lease will still need another vote by the board.

In public comment, Cynthia Conger, a Point Loma Realtor, told the board that the selling price of the Barnard and Mission Beach real estate is “peanuts for any developer.”

“You need to look at a very careful evaluation from more experienced people in this field that are not connected to developers,” she said.
Comments-icon Post a Comment
July 15, 2012
The school site is definitely not "ocean front" since, well you know, it doesn't front the ocean. You can't even see the ocean from there. It is a valuable piece of land regardless and I'm sure developers would love to get their hands on it for the right price. But a one time cash infusion that only covers 10% of this year's budget shortfall seems very, very short-sided. It seems like with a little more forethought, they could have figured out a way to generate a consistent cash flow stream from that asset instead of it sitting idle for decades and then selling it. But I guess lack of forethought is how you end up running an organization with a $120 million deficit to begin with...
July 05, 2012
The plan to sell the MB School property is a clear conflict with the Mission Beach Precise Community Plan. The Community plan designates the property for "The provision of adequate elementary and secondary education to all school age persons in Mission Beach and the encouragement of intensive use of the public school facility for other uses in addition

to elementary education such as special education, adult education, recreation and civic

and cultural activities." We cannot let the SDUSD sell public land intended for public benefit to developers to get one-time cash infusions to balance budgets. The precious public land will be gone forever.
Comments are back! Simply post the comment (it'll complain about you failing the human test) then simply click on the captcha and then click "Post Comment" again. Comments are also welcome on our Facebook page.